CarCabin

Tesla Model 3 vs Tesla Model Y

Data for the 2023 (Tesla Model 3) and 2025 (Tesla Model Y) model years. CarCabin Score aggregates NHTSA safety, EPA MPG, complaints, and recalls.

52
CarCabin Score
Mixed
40
Safety
/ 40
0
Fuel
/ 25
0
Rel.
/ 20
12
Rec.
/ 15
Safety
Combined MPG
n/a
Recalls (3yr)
4
Annual fuel cost
n/a
41
CarCabin Score
Mixed
40
Safety
/ 40
0
Fuel
/ 25
0
Rel.
/ 20
1
Rec.
/ 15
Safety
Combined MPG
n/a
Recalls (3yr)
19
Annual fuel cost
n/a

Side-by-side chart

Disclaimer. Comparison reflects indexed NHTSA and EPA data for the listed model years. CarCabin is not a dealer, mechanic, or automotive advisor. Always verify recall status at nhtsa.gov/recalls with your VIN.